July 19, 2024

bushwickwashnyc

Discover The Difference

Restaurant Delivery: Is it Ethical to Use Uber Eats and DoorDash?

Restaurant Delivery: Is it Ethical to Use Uber Eats and DoorDash?

Foodora Bike CourierA couple of days ago, the NYT featured a story about the ethics of using delivery services like Uber Eats and DoorDash (See: As Diners Flock to Delivery Apps, Restaurants Fear for Their Future). The basic gist of the story is that these services are predatory, in that they insist on such a large cut of the overall order price that, in some instances, the restaurant in question doesn’t make a dime on the order.

Just how big a cut do the delivery services take? Generally around 30%. (That’s true except where limited by law. In Jersey City, for example, delivery fees are limited to 10%.) So, in most places, if you order $100 worth of food, the restaurant only gets $70. In an industry where profit margins are often in the single-digit range, it’s easy to wonder how that’s remotely attractive, let alone sustainable.

And where does that leave you as a consumer? Suppose you’re someone living in a city where all the restaurants are closed except for pickup and delivery. And further suppose that you are someone who loves restaurant food, and who also wants to help their favourite restaurants survive. What are you to do?

The answer clearly depends on some details, here, and I’m no expert on this particular industry. Indeed, beyond having read Kitchen Confidential and spending too much on restaurant food myself, the industry is a bit of a mystery to me. So I spoke to a friend who is general manager for a small chain of 3 restaurants here in Toronto. I asked him why he dealt with food delivery services at all, given the bad rap those services get, and whether I should feel bad about ordering food that way. The conversation was pretty enlightening.

My friend confirmed that most food delivery services take a 30% share of the bill. How can that make sense? Why would a restaurant accept these deliveries demanding such a greedy share of the pie?

Here’s the explanation. He told me that way back in pre-Covid times, restaurants had a couple of different reasons for accepting the harsh terms offered by the delivery services. First, there’s marketing. Every Uber Eats and DoorDash order represents not just an order, but a potential new customer — one who might not previously have known about the restaurant, and who might just come to the restaurant in person next time, and then the restaurant gets full benefit.

Second, when you’ve already paid your rent and paid your staff to be on duty, an Uber Eats sale is an ‘incremental’ sale: if overhead is already paid, then fulfilling an Uber Eats order on top of that is kind of painless. “At the margin” (as economists say) an extra meal costs very little to produce, so even Uber Eats’s 30% leaves a healthy profit.

Now, fast forward to the Covid-19 pandemic: with restaurant doors shut, neither of the factors listed above would generally matter much. You can’t use DoorDash as a marketing ploy, because (here in Toronto at least) your doors are closed to that more lucrative in-restaurant dining. And if you’re not operating at full capacity, you may not necessarily have the capacity to treat a DoorDash order as a relatively easy addition to the kitchen’s duties. But today, in Canada at least, there are substantial government subsidies that keep cost of staffing manageable, so at least some restaurants are able to keep more staff available to fulfill delivery (and curb-side pickup) orders. And as of now, those orders (in places like Toronto, where restaurants are definitely closed to walk-in business), Uber Eats at the like are a lifeline.

Bottom line: if you have qualms about Uber Eats (etc.) it shouldn’t be because you think the restaurant is suffering. Uber Eats, DoorDash, and the like are helping, not hurting, your favourite restaurant.

Now, a major ethical question remains. In spite of what I’ve said above, the question remains whether services like Uber Eats and DoorDash are a good thing? After all, they charge restaurants very high fees, and restaurants are likely signing up for fear of being left out and jostled aside by the competition. And (though views vary) they arguably underpay their delivery drivers. And yet — interestingly — the services themselves still aren’t profitable. And while consumers benefit from the relative convenience of being able to enjoy restaurant-quality food at home, they’re also ultimately going to eat at least part of the increase in prices that will naturally go along with these companies having inserted themselves into the restaurant ‘value chain.’ (You surely didn’t think consumers wouldn’t end up footing the bill, directly or indirectly, did you?) So it’s tough, overall, to judge the coming of DoorDash and Uber Eats as a good thing. Yes, some form of delivery would be really great, if a model could be figured out that benefits everyone, but these organizations haven’t figured out how to do that yet.

The problem here is really a classic collective action problem. Because even if none of us is happy about the advent of these delivery services, in their present form, each of us benefits from the convenience they provide. And the same dilemma applies to the restaurants using these services. A given restaurant manager can regret what these companies are doing to the industry, but at the same time see dealing with them as good for her restaurant, in the here and now. And because of that pattern of incentives, everybody is motivated to keep participating in a system that they think is, on balance, a bad one. It’s a pernicious kind of problem.

What alternatives are there? Can a consumer do better by their favourite restaurant than to order via Uber Eats? There are a couple of alternatives. In some places, smaller, more equitably-minded delivery services have popped up, in some cases supported by municipal governments. And some restaurants are doing their own deliveries, though there are barriers to that becoming very common, not least among them the cost of hiring and insuring drivers.

So, what’s the result, from the perspective of ethical consumerism? If you think the model is regrettable, and don’t want to participate in it, then go ahead and avoid it. It’s perfectly reasonable to stand on principle, and some will say it’s even ethically required. But if your main ethical worry has to do with the fortunes of your favourite restaurant, and the people it employs, then it’s worth knowing that you’re helping them more by ordering via Uber Eats and DoorDash than by not ordering.

pga77 pga77 slot suster123 kijangwin ladangtoto rajatogel slot-gopay kakek zeus scatter-hitam scatter-hitam kijangwin suster123 scatter-hitam slot taiwan slot-gopay hoki99 slot linkaja slot ovo nenektogel gasing777 tumi123 bento123 fendi188 gasing777 66kbet scatter-pink scatter-hijau ladangtoto ladangtoto gudangtoto rajatogel nusantara4d ladangtoto scatter-hitam slot-bsi scatter-hitam ladangtoto slot-bri pga77 slot-goceng slot-10k opaltogel scatter-hitam jp188 ladangtoto slot-linkaja slot-cimb slot-gopay slot77 sbankjago sbca slot-qris ladangtoto slot-dana idnslot slot-mandiri slot-maybank ladangtoto scatter-hitam ultra889 sumseltoto medantoto rajampo raja88jp indoslot88 asiatoto88 mpltoto wajik777 tumi123 kembangtoto alexistogel mawartoto rajatogel wajik777 madu303 mpo888 sikat88 gucitoto pga77 pga77 ladangtoto olx188 gacor88 ayah4d pga77 pga77 gemilang4d ladangtoto petir388 kembangtoto sikat88 ying77 slot212 texas88 slot138 rp888 rumah258 cuan88 slot-bonanza scatter-hitam slot-dana kakek-merah rajampo lampung4d alay4d jambitoto manadototo binjaitoto pajaktoto popotogel 888slot jacktoto kaskustoto keitogel laku77 wing4d bostoto laetoto afktoto rudaltoto ojktoto pga77 rajagacor olxslot rajatogel jacktoto bento4d kaskustoto pga77 preman69 mpo808 mpoxtra838 rajatogel rajagacor ladangtoto asiatoto tumi123 olx188 bro138 galaxy77 asiatogel88 gacor88 rajatogel slot77 padangtoto rasa4d sdtoto omtogel ltdtoto dentoto rupiahtoto gacor88 pgbet slot-thailand mawartoto rajatogel rajatogel rudaltoto mawartoto topjitu toto188 mom4d 888slot sdtoto angkasa168 hondatoto 888slot bro138 scatter-hitam slot-zeus kaskustoto rajatogel tumi123 mustang303 api5000 senja777 super33 dewanaga89 hokibet dewa234 sizi99 cuanwin77 liga2000 88mega popi99 bento123 macauslot 888slot hoki178 jackpot108 gadunslot gacor88 king999 rajampo big777 kedai69 rp888 rajapaito ladangtoto rajatogel gtr11 slot99bet alba88 stars77 mangga2bet klik88 rans288 fin4d ceriabet leoslot88 agen108 dewasurga88 dragon222 gacorbos88 medusa88 pga77 pga77 pga77 surgawin homebet88 bento4d pga77 pga77 jago777 sgpslot api88 m77casino m77slot rajatogel bento4d m77casino m77slot hoki178 rudaltoto wajik777 gacor88 rajampo ladangtoto pga77 juragan69 texas88 mahjong69 galaxy77 pga77 hebat303 pga77 pga77 ladangtoto asiatoto inatogel toto88 jacktoto robintogel ladangtoto pga77 888slot wajikslot olx188 olxslot inatogel pga77 gacor88 pga77 bento4d robintogel asiatoto dewatoto gacor88 888slot slot-zeus slot-dana pga77 pga77 zodiak69 licin4d pga77 888dewa asian303 888slot indosultan88 slot-zeus Slot-Mahjong 66kbet rumah258 ying77 betseru pga77 scatter-hitam jayagaming lido88 hoki178 batik77 medusa88 duniabet303 royaltoto indosultan88 wdbos 888slot 888dewa wajik777 royaltoto wdbos gacor88 raja328 planet77 dewi188 slot-zeus slot-dana dewihoki fendi188 hoki178 batik77 pga77 naga138 robintogel surga55 pga77 slot-maxwin rajampo pga77 lotte4d 888slot pga77 angkasa168 pga77 cermin4d bento4d pga77 toto88 operatoto gacor88 olx188 m77casino m77casino pga77 pga77 888slot api5000 pga77 pga77 m77casino pga77 juragan69 pga77 presidenslot bighoki alexabet88 g200m m77casino mentari138 hoki178 olympus88 mega55 pga77 pga77 royaltoto panen77 pga77 garuda4d pga77 royaltoto sultantoto pga77 aksara4d arwanatoto bobatoto pga77 gacor88 m77casino 888slot 66kbet sritoto m77casino iramatogel mantra88 ajaib88 pga77 dewaslot88 pisang123 pga77 pga77 gas138 olx188 muara777 gacor88 dewaslot99 royaltoto pusat4d bos5000 pga77 888slot scatter-hitam pga77 sdtoto wis77 pamanslot meme4d diana4d prada4d neko4d angsa4d sinar777 brio4d pga77 okgas21 scatter-hitam slot-bonanza 98toto kingdomtoto direkturtoto rupiahtoto pga77 pga77 wongtoto akartoto kompastoto sultantoto gacor88 sumbartoto planet4d ngamenjitu 888slot royaltoto pga77 dorahoki pga77 pga77 pos4d djarumtoto kenzototo jejuslot mega777 royaltoto nirwana88 pga77 888slot pga77 pga77 palu4d royaltoto rogtoto omtogel Slot-Mahjong pga77 slot-demo pga77 slot-maxwin slot-zeus shitam sthailand pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 888slot pos4d pga77 m77casino pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 pga77 royaltoto sultantoto pos4d api5000 888slot